Apple slides about 4% before the bell as John Ternus warns memory prices are 'unprecedented', and Palantir drops despite its beat
Apple beat on sales and guided the holiday quarter above estimates, but a 45% to 46% gross margin forecast overshadowed the numbers. Palantir fell on slowing contract bookings. Both reactions land on Election Day.
Illustration: Invested Alpha
Two of Monday night's biggest earnings reports beat Wall Street's numbers, and both stocks are falling anyway. Apple and Palantir were among the weakest large stocks in premarket trading on Tuesday, a reminder that in this market the outlook and the details beneath the headline figures carry more weight than the beat itself.
Apple: the sales beat and the margin warning
Apple's first quarter under CEO John Ternus looked solid on the surface. Revenue for the fiscal fourth quarter came in at $114.48 billion, ahead of the $113.39 billion consensus, and earnings of $2.10 a share topped the $1.99 estimate, according to LSEG data cited by CNBC and Reuters. Revenue grew about 12% from a year earlier. iPhone revenue reached $57.58 billion, above the $56.54 billion analysts expected, and Mac sales also beat. iPad revenue of $6.23 billion missed the $6.7 billion estimate.
Apple also guided the December quarter above expectations. The company expects revenue to grow 7% to 10% from a year earlier, compared with an average analyst estimate of about 6%, CNBC reported, citing LSEG. Chief Financial Officer Kevan Parekh said that would still be Apple's best quarter ever, despite constrained supply, TheStreet reported.
The problem was profitability. Apple forecast a gross margin of 45% to 46% for the holiday quarter, down from 47.9% in the September quarter and below the 46.3% average estimate compiled by LSEG. Bloomberg, cited by TheStreet, put the consensus closer to 47%. Apple also guided services revenue growth to 8% to 9%, short of the roughly 10% to 10.7% analysts had expected, according to Reuters and TheStreet.
"What we're seeing with memory pricing right now is unprecedented." - Apple CEO John Ternus on Monday's earnings call, as quoted by The Guardian
Ternus told analysts that memory costs in the December quarter would be even higher than in the September period, The Guardian reported, and Parekh said Apple expects those costs to keep rising into next year, according to Reuters. Demand for memory chips from AI data centers has pushed prices sharply higher across the industry. Apple raised prices on iPads and MacBooks in June and on iPhones in September, and Ternus said those increases "provided some offset," Reuters reported.
There is a further wrinkle in the September-quarter margin. Apple said tariff refunds added 5 cents to earnings per share, according to CNBC and Reuters, and TheStreet calculated that roughly one percentage point of the 47.9% gross margin came from those refunds. That makes the step down to 45% to 46% look smaller than the headline comparison, but it still points to a decline.
Apple shares closed Monday at $338.32, down 1.83%, before the report. Premarket indications on Tuesday showed declines of about 3.8% to 4.5%, depending on the time of the reading, according to CNBC, Bloomberg and Stocktwits.
Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning
We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.
Palantir: a big quarter, slower bookings
Palantir delivered the kind of quarter that would have sent the stock sharply higher a few months ago. Revenue jumped 96% from a year earlier to $2.31 billion, ahead of the roughly $2.18 billion consensus, and adjusted earnings of $0.44 a share beat the $0.41 estimate, Investing.com and Schwab Network reported. U.S. commercial revenue topped government revenue for the first time, CNBC noted. In his shareholder letter, CEO Alex Karp described corporate interest in the company's sovereign AI offerings as "extraordinary and ravenous," according to Stocktwits.
Investors focused instead on bookings. Total contract value for the quarter was $2.918 billion, up 6% from a year earlier, compared with 49% growth in the second quarter, Investing.com reported. U.S. commercial total contract value grew 11%, after surging 153% in the second quarter, according to Investing.com and a William Blair note cited by CNBC. Bookings measure deals signed, so a slowdown raises questions about how fast revenue can grow next year.
Not every analyst read it that way. A Piper Sandler note cited by CNBC said investors would look for evidence that the 11% growth was "a fluke of duration and not something structural," adding: "We believe that is the case."
Palantir shares closed Monday at $178.34, down 3.13% in the regular session. They were down about 6% to 7.8% in premarket trading, according to Investing.com and CNBC.
How it fits Tuesday's market
The two reports add to the pressure on technology stocks heading into the midterm elections. Nasdaq 100 futures were up about 0.3% to 0.5% before dawn, while S&P 500 futures were roughly flat and Dow futures were down about 0.5%, according to Bloomberg, Stocktwits and TipRanks. On Monday, the S&P 500 fell 0.51% to 7,541.40 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 1.07% to 25,164.32, while the Dow rose 0.41% to 51,983.98.
The pattern from last week holds: investors are rewarding companies on what the next few quarters look like, and punishing cost pressure and slowing momentum even when the latest quarter clears the bar. AMD, which reports after Tuesday's close, faces the same test.