DELL · HPE · NTAP · NVDA

Dell has lost 17% in two sessions as the AI hardware selloff hits $1 trillion for the week

A Barclays downgrade questioned how much of the server boom is real demand and how much is pricier memory. Dell and HPE fell about 7% each on Thursday, and chip stocks from Seoul to Tokyo kept sliding.

Invested Alpha Staff · 6 min read

Illustration: Invested Alpha

The broad market found its footing on Thursday. The companies that build the machines behind artificial intelligence did not. Dell Technologies and Hewlett Packard Enterprise ranked among the worst performers in the S&P 500 for a second straight day, Investopedia reported, and the global selloff in chip and AI hardware stocks pushed the week's losses past $1 trillion.

Two days, 17%

Dell closed down 6.8% at $473.39, according to Yahoo Finance data. That followed an 11.3% drop on Wednesday, leaving the stock about 17% below where it finished on Tuesday. Hewlett Packard Enterprise fell 7.1% to $58.63 and NetApp lost 3.4%. Super Micro Computer, which was not part of any rating change, slipped about 1.9%.

The trigger was a Barclays note published on Wednesday that cut Dell, HPE and NetApp to equal weight from overweight. The analysts argued that enterprise spending on AI has not yet taken off in the way the stocks' gains implied. "We don't see a meaningful AI inflection yet," they wrote, according to Investopedia, adding that higher prices have propped up revenues.

That second point is the heart of the call. A global memory shortage has pushed up the cost of components that go into servers and storage systems. When the price of what a company sells rises, its revenue grows even if it ships the same number of units. Barclays' argument was that part of the recent strength at the hardware makers reflects those higher prices rather than a surge in new customers.

A rate story as much as an AI story

The downgrade landed in a market already worried about borrowing costs. Wednesday's hot consumer price report briefly pushed the odds of an October Federal Reserve rate hike above 50%, and higher rates raise the cost for companies borrowing to build data centers and buy AI chips. On Wednesday, the cost of insuring the debt of some AI companies against default, including Oracle and CoreWeave, rose to record highs, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence data cited by CNBC TV18.

Thursday's decline in Treasury yields eased some of that pressure for the wider market. The 10-year yield fell to about 5.09%, and the S&P 500 finished higher. But the money that left AI hardware went mostly to health care, consumer and materials stocks rather than back into chips, according to Reuters.

Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning

We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.

Get the free newsletter

The selloff went global

The pain was sharpest in Asia, where AI-linked stocks had been some of the year's biggest winners. South Korea's KOSPI fell almost 8% on Thursday, Reuters reported, and Japan's Nikkei 225 dropped nearly 5%. Memory makers SK Hynix and Samsung Electronics, which together account for more than half of the KOSPI's market value, fell about 11% and 9%, according to Business Insider. In Tokyo, chip-testing equipment maker Advantest plunged almost 14% and SoftBank Group lost 7.9%, CNBC reported.

CNBC calculated that 20 of the most valuable AI and semiconductor companies worldwide have collectively shed more than $1 trillion in market value so far this week. MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan closed 3.12% lower, its biggest one-day drop since late July, according to Reuters.

U.S. chip stocks pared losses

On Wall Street, the declines among chipmakers were smaller by the close than they were in the morning. The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index was down 1.7% in early trading, Reuters reported. Nvidia finished down 1.84% and Taiwan Semiconductor's U.S.-listed shares lost 1.8%, per Yahoo Finance, a day after the chipmaker reported a record quarterly profit and beat estimates.

That reaction to TSMC is a useful marker of the mood. Strong results from the companies at the center of the AI build-out are no longer enough on their own. Investors are asking a different question: whether the spending can keep growing while borrowing costs rise and while buyers such as corporate IT departments take longer to commit.

What to watch next

For the hardware makers, the next real evidence will come from orders and backlogs in upcoming earnings reports, not from analyst ratings. For the broader AI trade, the bond market matters as much as any product cycle. If yields keep falling, the financing worries that fueled this week's selling may fade. If Friday's remarks from Fed Chair Kevin Warsh revive talk of an October hike, the debt-heavy corners of the trade are the most exposed.

Thursday's split screen, a rising Dow beside a falling Dell, shows how selective investors have become. The market is not abandoning AI wholesale. It is sorting which parts of the build-out can carry their costs in a world of 5% Treasury yields.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice.

Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning

We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.

Unsubscribe anytime.