Hot CPI pushed October hike bets as high as 60%. Then the Fed's own officials talked them down
Mary Daly and Michelle Bowman said there is time to wait, Austan Goolsbee called the report discouraging and the Beige Book counted diesel 21 times. Here is how the rate debate looks heading into Thursday's PPI.
Illustration: Invested Alpha
Wednesday showed how quickly the market can swing on a single inflation report, and how quickly Federal Reserve officials can swing it back.
On Wednesday morning, traders in fed funds futures priced less than a 25% chance that the Fed would raise rates again at its October 27-28 meeting, according to the CME FedWatch tool as cited by MarketWatch. Then the September consumer price index came in above forecasts, and those odds jumped.
How far the odds moved
Different gauges captured different peaks. LSEG-compiled data showed a 60% chance of a quarter-point increase during the session, up from 21.6% before the report, according to Reuters. CNBC said pricing for an October hike rose to 50%. By Wednesday evening, market pricing was close to 40%, according to InvestingLive.
The trigger was a report that came in hotter on almost every line. Headline CPI rose 0.6% in September and 3.7% from a year earlier, above the 3.6% forecast. Core CPI rose 0.3% on the month, against expectations of 0.2%, and 2.6% from a year earlier.
Then the officials spoke
Within hours, several Fed officials offered a more patient message.
San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly told Reuters that further rate increases are more likely than not to be needed, but she signaled no need to move at the October meeting. She said she did not feel any urgency and preferred to take time for a thoughtful decision rather than react to limited information. She attributed much of the jump in headline inflation to gasoline prices and said core inflation remains sticky, as expected.
Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman also said the central bank can wait for a clearer picture, according to CNBC and Shanghai Metals Market, noting that inflation remains above target.
Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee sounded more concerned. Speaking to Yahoo Finance, he called the September figures discouraging and pointed to services inflation running above 5% a year, which he said cannot be blamed on tariffs or oil, according to InvestingLive. He did not say how the Fed should respond in the near term.
What the Beige Book added
The Fed's Beige Book, a survey of business conditions across its 12 districts released the same afternoon, pointed in the same direction as Goolsbee. Three districts described price growth as robust. Diesel was mentioned 21 times, up from two times in the previous report, and was the most commonly cited cost driver among Dallas Fed contacts, according to InvestingLive and Pomegra.
That matters because diesel runs through freight, farming and air travel. When fuel costs show up in the price of shipping and services, the Fed has a harder time treating an oil spike as temporary. The Beige Book also described the labor market as stuck in a low-hire, low-fire pattern and said housing was being weighed down by mortgage rates near three-year highs.
Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning
We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.
The market's verdict, for now
Bond traders sided with the patient camp overnight. The 10-year Treasury yield fell to a three-week low, between roughly 5.09% and 5.13% in readings cited by Reuters and CNBC, and the dollar slipped from the 18-month high it reached after the CPI data.
"Despite the whole CPI number coming slightly stronger than expected, I think markets have sort of taken the view that maybe it was not hot enough to force the Fed's hand for October," Khoon Goh, head of Asia research at ANZ, told Reuters. He added that the October meeting falls just days before the midterm elections, which may make markets reluctant to price a move more aggressively.
December remains the meeting many forecasters see as the more likely timing. Seema Shah, chief global strategist at Principal Asset Management, told Reuters she expects further hikes in December and early 2027.
Why it matters for investors
Rate expectations feed directly into mortgage rates, borrowing costs for companies and the valuations investors are willing to pay for growth stocks. Wednesday's selloff in AI-linked shares showed how sensitive that corner of the market has become to every shift in the Fed outlook.
What to watch today
The September producer price index at 8:30 a.m. ET, with economists expecting a 0.5% to 0.6% monthly rise, is the next test. Retail sales and jobless claims arrive at the same time. Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack, generally seen as one of the committee's more hawkish voices, is among the officials scheduled to speak. With the Fed's pre-meeting quiet period approaching, each remaining public comment carries extra weight.