Kevin Warsh left December open, and the 8:30 a.m. GDP and PCE inflation data now have to answer it
A day after the Fed held rates in a 10-2 vote, traders price a December hike at roughly 78% to 87%. Economists expect PCE inflation to rise to about 3.6% from 3.4%. Oil is down on reports of renewed U.S.-Iran outreach.
Illustration: Invested Alpha
Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh handed the next move to the data, and the data arrives this morning. At 8:30 a.m. ET, the government publishes its first estimate of third-quarter GDP alongside September's personal income and spending report, which includes the PCE price index, the Fed's preferred inflation gauge.
The releases land less than a day after the Fed kept its benchmark rate in a 3.75% to 4% range. The vote was 10-2: Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack both wanted a quarter-point hike, according to CNBC and Mitrade. Warsh declined to offer forward guidance on December, according to Investing.com and Mitrade.
Where December odds stand
Traders still lean toward a hike at the December meeting, but estimates differ by source and timestamp. Reuters cited an 85% probability from CME's FedWatch tool after Wednesday's decision, Mitrade put it at 85% to 87%, InvestingLive at roughly 84%, and CNBC reported about 78% early Thursday. All of those readings point the same way: the market expects the Fed's next move to be up.
Warsh said the Fed would "deliver price stability" and described the economy as expanding at a "strong pace," according to Mitrade. He also announced changes to the meeting calendar: starting in 2027, one of the eight annual meetings will focus only on strategy, and in 2028 two will, leaving six rate-setting meetings, CNBC reported.
What economists expect at 8:30
- Headline PCE inflation: about 3.6% to 3.7% year over year, up from 3.4% in August, and about 0.5% month over month.
- Core PCE, excluding food and energy: about 3.1% year over year versus 3.0%, and 0.3% month over month versus 0.2%.
- Third-quarter GDP: about 3.1% to 3.2% annualized growth, up from 2.2% in the second quarter.
Those forecasts come from Investing.com, InvestingLive and Mitrade. Weekly jobless claims are released at the same time. A hotter core reading would support the case the two dissenters made, while a softer one could revive talk that one hike was enough, Mitrade and InvestingLive noted.
The bond market's read
Treasury yields split after the decision. The 2-year yield fell to about 4.70%, while the 10-year yield rose to roughly 5.04% by Wednesday's close, according to Investing.com and Mitrade. The 10-year was near 5.00% in European trading on Thursday, Investing.com said.
That steepening reflects two different worries, Reuters reported in an analysis: Warsh did not commit to a December hike, which nudged short-term rate bets lower, while longer-dated bonds came under pressure from concern about persistent inflation and the cost of holding long-term government debt.
Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning
We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.
Oil and gold
Oil fell on Thursday after the Wall Street Journal reported that Vice President JD Vance had reached out to Iranian Security Council chief Mohsen Rezaei to try to restart peace talks, CNBC reported. Brent crude was trading around $113 to $114 a barrel and West Texas Intermediate around $100.70 to $101.30, according to CNBC and Report.az data.
Oil prices have been above $100 a barrel since the Iran war began, adding to inflation pressure, Reuters noted. That is part of why economists expect headline PCE inflation to run ahead of the core measure in this morning's report.
Gold slipped as well. Spot gold traded between roughly $4,030 and $4,055 an ounce in early readings from CNBC, Moneycontrol and Exa market data, down a fraction of a percent, as traders weighed the chance of higher U.S. rates. Higher rates raise the opportunity cost of holding gold, which pays no interest.
The rest of Thursday
The European Central Bank also announces its policy decision on Thursday morning, U.S. time, according to Investing.com. In the U.S., Amazon, Apple and Intel report after the close, and stock futures are already split: Nasdaq 100 futures were down more than 1% on Alphabet's slide while Dow futures were higher.
The Fed has been clear that it wants more evidence before it moves again. This morning's inflation and growth numbers are the first big piece of that evidence, and they arrive just days before next week's midterm elections and about six weeks before the December meeting.