UNH · HUM · ELV · PANW · CRWD

UnitedHealth and Humana sink on a Medicare audit proposal, dragging the Dow down 561 points while cybersecurity stocks rally

UnitedHealth fell 10.21% and Humana 12.98% as investors weighed a federal plan to extrapolate Medicare Advantage audit findings across plans' payments. Palo Alto Networks jumped 9.9%, then beat estimates and raised its outlook after the bell.

Invested Alpha Staff · 5 min read
UnitedHealth and Humana sink on a Medicare audit proposal, dragging the Dow down 561 points while cybersecurity stocks rally

Photo: https://kaboompics.com/ / Pexels

Health insurers took the biggest hit on Wall Street on Wednesday, and because UnitedHealth is one of the heaviest stocks in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the selling showed up clearly in the blue-chip index. The Dow fell 561.25 points, or 1.11%, to 50,198.17, while the S&P 500 slipped 0.23% and the Nasdaq Composite rose 0.42%.

UnitedHealth Group closed down 10.21% at $349.91, according to Yahoo Finance data. Humana fell further, losing 12.98% to $385.78. Elevance Health dropped 7.63%, CVS Health 5.2% and Cigna 2.96%. It was the second straight day of losses for the group, StockAnalysis reported, and UnitedHealth makes up about 4.3% of the Dow, according to Yahoo Finance.

What CMS proposed

The trigger was a proposal from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services published on Monday. The rule, called CRUSH, short for Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, targets fraud across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program and the Health Insurance Marketplace. CMS says it could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over 10 years, according to StockAnalysis and TipRanks.

The part that hit insurers is about audits. Medicare Advantage plans are paid more for members with more diagnoses on record, and CMS audits a sample of medical records to check that those diagnoses are documented. Under the proposal, CMS would extrapolate what those audits find to a plan's wider payments, starting with audits of 2018. The agency estimates that would recover about $9 billion in overpayments for each payment year.

"Every taxpayer dollar lost to fraud is a dollar that cannot support the care these programs were created to provide." - CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz

Analysts at Oppenheimer expect a fight. A federal court threw out a comparable framework in 2025, and the firm wrote that "we believe CMS will be subject to the same legal challenges that it faced in 2025," Yahoo Finance reported. Oppenheimer also said most of the projected savings would come from clawing back past payments, with recoveries concentrated in 2028 through 2030, and that insurers would likely pass added costs into their bids for future plan years if the rule survives.

Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning

We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.

Get the free newsletter

Cybersecurity went the other way

On the other side of the tape, cybersecurity stocks rallied hard during the regular session. SentinelOne closed up 10.35% at $23.34, Palo Alto Networks rose 9.9% to $339.92 and CrowdStrike gained 7.95% to $237.03, according to Yahoo Finance data. No single catalyst was cited for the move during trading. CNBC on Wednesday highlighted a string of recent outages at businesses and government agencies that has put a spotlight on so-called digital resilience stocks.

Palo Alto then reported after the bell. Revenue for its fiscal first quarter rose 39% from a year earlier to $3.44 billion, ahead of the $3.31 billion LSEG consensus cited by CNBC. Adjusted earnings were $1.05 a share against 97 cents expected. Next-Generation Security annual recurring revenue grew 66% to $9.73 billion, and remaining performance obligations rose 35% to $21.0 billion, according to the company's release.

The company raised its full-year guidance to adjusted earnings of $4.26 to $4.30 a share on revenue of $14.52 billion to $14.57 billion. Analysts had expected $4.18 and $14.16 billion, according to LSEG via CNBC. Palo Alto also announced plans to acquire Applied Compute, which it said would let it deliver secure open-weight AI models to customers.

"We had a strong start to the year with a record Q1 and delivered one of our highest NGS ARR beats ever as our customers turn to us to protect them against an unprecedented threat environment," Chief Executive Nikesh Arora said in the release. CNBC said the shares rose about 7% in extended trading, with CrowdStrike and Okta higher in sympathy.

Retailers also had a strong day

Consumer discretionary was the best-performing sector, Reuters said, helped by a 3.82% gain in Amazon. TJX Companies jumped 8.05% after forecasting strong annual sales ahead of the holiday season, and Target rose 4.01% after giving an upbeat holiday outlook, according to Reuters and Yahoo Finance data. Take-Two Interactive rose 6.22% ahead of the rollout of Grand Theft Auto VI.

What carries into Thursday

For insurers, the question is whether the CRUSH proposal holds up through the comment period and any legal challenge, and how companies address it in their next public comments. For cybersecurity, Palo Alto's after-hours move will be tested in Thursday's regular session, after a day in which the group had already rallied. Walmart, a bellwether for the consumer, reports on Thursday.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice.

Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning

We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.

Unsubscribe anytime.