Kevin Warsh says AI could disappoint and send stock valuations lower, as the 10-year yield eases to 5.12% and oil settles at $85.72
In his first visit to a regional Fed bank as chairman, Warsh laid out three scenarios for "super intelligence", including one where returns turn down and stocks fall. Treasury yields dipped, and crude slid more than 3% as Gulf shipments recovered.
Photo: Cody Beale / Pexels
Kevin Warsh spent Monday in San Francisco talking about the technology that has driven much of the stock market's gains, and he did not only talk about the upside. In opening remarks at a Fed conference on productivity and jobs, the Federal Reserve chairman described a scenario in which the AI boom disappoints and stocks fall. On a day when AI stocks led the market lower, the timing stood out.
Three ways it could go
The conference, hosted by the Fed Board and the San Francisco Fed, was the work of one of five task forces Warsh has set up as chairman. He told the audience it was his "very first visit to a Reserve Bank as Chairman." Throughout his prepared text, he used the term "super intelligence," or SI, instead of artificial intelligence, calling it "an entirely new force in economic life and society."
Warsh said the technology "will have significant impact on the economy, with important implications for monetary policy down the road," CNBC reported. He then walked through several outcomes. In the most optimistic one, productivity gains lift economic growth above its long-run average while employment stays near full capacity.
In a less positive case, automation "could push the jobless rate above levels consistent with full employment," as some jobs are replaced rather than helped by the technology, Axios reported. And in a third, AI simply disappoints.
"After significant capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns could turn down and equity valuations could fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment." - Fed Chairman Kevin Warsh
"In time, the economy would recover, but without the productivity gains," he added, according to CNBC and Axios. Axios noted that Warsh described these as "illustrative scenarios, not forecasts," in a speech that was broadly optimistic. "Humans are the designers and the builders, and humans must be the deciders," he said.
AP pointed out one omission: Warsh did not mention inflation, even though many of his colleagues blame the data-center build-out for speeding up price increases.
Yields slip as stocks fall
Treasury yields moved lower as investors stepped back from stocks. The 10-year yield closed at 5.12%, down from 5.15% on Friday, according to Treasury Department data, and Yahoo Finance data matched. The 2-year yield, which is most sensitive to Fed expectations, fell to 4.83% from 4.88%, while the 30-year eased to 5.46% from 5.47%.
The moves were small next to last week's sell-off in bonds, which followed a 6.5% annual rise in producer prices, the highest in almost four years, CNBC said. Heading into the week, futures markets had largely priced a quarter-point increase at the Fed's Dec. 8-9 meeting, according to CME FedWatch data cited by CNBC. The Fed's benchmark rate sits at 3.75% to 4%.
Monday's only major economic report was mixed. The New York Fed's Empire State manufacturing index fell 17.7 points to 7.8 in November, well below the 18.0 economists expected, according to Newsquawk and The Econonaut. But its employment gauge rose to 18.1, the highest since June 2022, and the prices-paid index fell to 45.9 from 59.5.
Get Free Investment Ideas In Your Inbox Every Morning
We follow the latest trends so you don't have to.
Oil drops despite Gulf attacks
Crude prices fell sharply even after a weekend of violence in the Gulf. West Texas Intermediate for December delivery settled $2.84 lower at $85.72 a barrel, according to Newsquawk, a drop CNBC put at 3.21%. WTI traded between $84.34 and $89.49 during the session.
Newsquawk said the weekend brought an Iranian strike on an air base in Bahrain, and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard reported that two tankers hit mines in the Strait of Hormuz. But any rally was capped after i24 News reported that the U.S. was not considering imminent airstrikes against Iran.
CNBC said shipments through the Strait of Hormuz are recovering. The International Energy Agency said on Friday that it now expects supply to run ahead of demand in the fourth quarter, reversing an earlier forecast for a deficit, CNBC reported. Goldman Sachs said in a Sunday note that it expects Brent to average $88 a barrel in 2027.
Gold stays under pressure
Gold edged lower again. Spot gold traded near $3,856 an ounce late Monday, down about 0.6%, according to GoldPrice.com and Exa market data. A strong dollar and expectations of tighter Fed policy kept sellers in control, the German financial site Ad Hoc News said. Gold futures lost 4.70% last week, their worst week since early June, according to Guardian Gold.
What carries into Tuesday
October retail sales arrive Tuesday morning, followed by Nvidia's results after the close, a report that will test the same AI spending story Warsh discussed. The minutes of the Fed's October meeting come out on Wednesday.